Blue Shell Incident: Reloaded Had to use an alt for this one.
One of the contributors blocked me over some low scoring reviews.
The collab itself has a score of 3.69/5 and no awards, which is unusually low for a collab of this scale with over 100 creators. This feat alone is enough for me to give some stars, but the scenes themselves were mostly low-quality.
To give some comparison with a different collab, The Spongebob Rehydrated Collab was posted here a month earlier and had over 400 animators spent years completely redoing the Spongebob movie, and both parts have a score of 4.8/5 and are now in the Top 50.
The reason: All of the parts were good, or I assume so, since I didn't watch the entire thing. There might've been a few that were mediocre at worst.
= UPDATE = | After someone pointed out some SBRehydrated scenes were 'shitty' and I started watching more scenes, this info is out of date. They weren't all good, but there are more good movies to bad movies
A collab on the same scale as BSI:R should've easily surpassed 4 stars, but scenes animated with Roblox, low effort 'comic book style' drawings, live action, SMG4-esque machinimas, PNGs tweening around like I used to do in my first year of 'animation', and scenes done in 3D Movie Maker (which the original was already made with) end up getting accepted a whole lot more and let's just say it don't make Newgrounds happy, and the score starts to drop.
I'm not knockin' on Vinesauce Joel or the original BSI, which were great on YouTube. It's just that a good portion of the parts in the Reloaded collab weren't exactly NG friendly. However, there are some good bits to this collab. The audio in the original BSI was compressed by 3DMM, whereas here, a higher quality version of the audio is used. Also, some parts, such as two that TMNTSan did, were animated pretty well. Their part "Death by Shovel" has a higher score than the entire collab itself, which says something!
https://www.newgrounds.com/portal/view/845063
The scene in 14:44 where Luigi is flushed down a toilet is also really good as well. I thought that was the best one.
Waltman13's also deserve an honorable mention. They were good too, albeit with some help with scene 123 (which looks like it uses the Powerpuff Girls artstyle).
All in all, great collab, but not really Newgrounds material. but I didn't really watch the original or this version from beginning to end. I really don't have the time.
~frog~
